EssaysForStudent.com - Free Essays, Term Papers & Book Notes
Search

False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research

By:   •  Research Paper  •  1,973 Words  •  December 15, 2009  •  1,849 Views

Page 1 of 8

Essay title: False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research

False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research

Categorization and social projection are important ways that people can more successfully navigate their social environment. People need to know that there are others in their in-group that share the same attitudes and behaviors as they do. If people are unable to determine how many people in their environment share their attitudes and behaviors, it would be more difficult to engage in social situations without offending or contradicting others. For this reason, false consensus is an interesting offshoot of this important idea. The false consensus effect refers to the fact that people have a tendency to over-estimate the proportion of the population that shares an attitude or behavior with him or her.

Much of the research on false consensus has demonstrated that people tend to over project how many members of their in-group are likely to share their attitudes and behaviors. This effect diminishes when comparing to an out-group. It is thought that this occurs because people feel that people who they do not consider to share a group identity with will likely have different basic attitudes and behaviors than they.

An important aspect of the literature is that the vast majority used college students as the primary subjects. While this is extremely convenient for researchers, it may not give us a clear picture about false consensus, in that it is possible that college students' limited "real-world experience" may be influencing their projections. Also, almost all of the behavior measures were taken by self-report. This is somewhat necessary, as many of the behaviors would be difficult to measure directly (e.g., drug use) without a breach of ethics. This too is a source of potential source of error, it is likely that the self-reports would under-estimate the proportion of the population that engages in a particular behavior.

The astute reader may notice that this review does not include any papers that did not find a false consensus effect. The reason for this is not that this paper is not representative of the literature, but rather, that it is. The uniformity of the literature suggests that the phenomenon is fairly common. Some interesting arguments as to why this is are motivational or cognitive in nature. The motivational premise is based in the idea that people are motivated to believe that they have a place in their social environment. This argument is a based in self-justification, in that if many people share a given belief or behavior, it makes it easier to justify that this attitude or behavior is either right, or not as bad as it might seem. The cognitive argument centers on the availability heuristic, in that if one has a particular attitude or belief, it is easier to think of examples of people who share that belief because they have themselves as a primary example. Because both of these arguments make the same predictions, the value of each will not be presented here.

In 1977, Ross, Greene and House performed on of the first experiments on false consensus. In the first experiment of this study, the subjects (undergraduate students at the authors' university) were presented with a story that dealt with common situations for the time period (supermarket, term paper, traffic ticket, and space program referendum). At the end of the story, there was a clear behavioral choice, and subjects were asked to indicate what percentage of their peers would be for and against the behavioral choice. Finally, subjects were asked to state whether they felt that someone who would perform the behaviors listed was a typical or atypical representative of someone of the same age and sex as they were. It was found that for each story, subjects felt that a typical person would make the same behavior decision as they did, giving us a hint that a false consensus effect may exist.

This type of study is an interesting way to observe consensus effects, though it is impossible to determine whether or not the subjects' own behavior would actually mirror the behavior indicated during testing. Secondly, it is difficult to determine why a person would say that a typical person would not do as they would, in that generally, people do not think of themselves as atypical. It seems that the only way a subject would make a counter-behavioral statement would be if they knew they were atypical members of the group.

In a second experiment (experiment 4 of the paper), subjects were actually put in situations, and later asked how many others they felt would do the same. This has the distinct advantage of including actual behavior. In order to accomplish this, the subjects were asked to wear a sign with one of two messages ("Eat at Joe's" or "Repent"). Subjects were university students who were participating under the guise of an experiment designed

Continue for 7 more pages »  •  Join now to read essay False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research and other term papers or research documents
Download as (for upgraded members)
txt
pdf
Citation Generator

(2009, 12). False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research. EssaysForStudent.com. Retrieved 12, 2009, from https://www.essaysforstudent.com/essays/False-Consensus-Effect-A-Focused-Review-of-Research/26459.html

"False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research" EssaysForStudent.com. 12 2009. 2009. 12 2009 <https://www.essaysforstudent.com/essays/False-Consensus-Effect-A-Focused-Review-of-Research/26459.html>.

"False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research." EssaysForStudent.com. EssaysForStudent.com, 12 2009. Web. 12 2009. <https://www.essaysforstudent.com/essays/False-Consensus-Effect-A-Focused-Review-of-Research/26459.html>.

"False Consensus Effect: A Focused Review of Research." EssaysForStudent.com. 12, 2009. Accessed 12, 2009. https://www.essaysforstudent.com/essays/False-Consensus-Effect-A-Focused-Review-of-Research/26459.html.